Christmas Trifle!

This trifle will look smashing on your Christmas table!!! Layers of custard and jelly, studded with cake and piled high with cream and fruit, it looks stunning in a trifle dish but otherwise just use a glass bowl!

TOP TIP: you can buy the cake and custard ready made, but I really recommend making the jelly yourself. It’s such a major component in trifle, it makes all the difference – and it’s SUPER easy!

Christmas Trifle

The first time I made trifle, I used raspberry flavoured Aeroplane jelly and store bought custard. It looked so fabulous, I was beaming with pride. Blinded by the beauty of the trifle, I completely forgot the first rule of cooking – it doesn’t matter how pretty it looks or how good the photos are if it tastes meh.

One big bite, and I wrinkled my nose with distaste. The jelly flavour was just so incredibly artificial, it was really off-putting because its artificial-ness is such a stark contrast to all the other flavours going on in the trifle.

Now before you go thinking I’m some kind of food snob, let me just say this – I actually don’t mind Aeroplane jelly on it’s own, there’s something sentimental about it. And I thoroughly encourage you to use store bought custard if you are pressed for time (though homemade is really sooooo good!).

BUT PLEASE DO NOT USE FLAVOURED AEROPLANE JELLY IN THIS TRIFLE!!!!

I promise you, it is so crazy simple to make real juice flavoured jelly! All you have to do is use gelatine which is very cheap and easy to use!

NOTE: I used to use flavourless Aeroplane Jelly for the jelly (click here for the original recipe). It’s no longer available, so the recipe uses plain gelatine instead which was preciously an alternative in the notes. Video not yet refilmed. Will do so next year!

For those of you wondering about the difference: Flavourless Aeroplane Jelly was sweet so the recipe called for unsweetened cranberry juice. Gelatine powder is unsweetened so we need to use sweetened cranberry juice.

I think the reason why it makes such a difference to use real Cranberry Juice for the jelly instead of flavoured Aeroplane Jelly is because there is so much of it in the trifle. Also, the jelly is slightly more concentrated in flavour than when you make it per the packet directions because the liquid to crystals ratio is lower, to ensure the jelly is firm enough to withstand the weight of everything piled on top of it.

Other than that, I have no other trifle rules. In fact, I’m pretty relaxed about everything else. Use whatever cake you want for the base – store bought or homemade madeira, Pound Cake or Vanilla Cake, even Christmas cake. Use homemade or store bought custard. Use any fruit you want – even canned is fine. I’d even say it’s pretty ok to use whipped cream out of a spray can over using flavoured Aeroplane jelly!!!

If you want quite neat layers, like depicted, please do follow the recipe carefully for each layer. In my trifle making life, there have been some not-so-pretty trifle efforts (albeit tasty!). Mainly bleeding between the layers, and jelly that set too much before ladling onto the custard, so it looked broken and split, rather than a clear jelly to show off the fruit in that layer.

If you’re catering for a large group this Christmas and/or you want a dessert you can make days in advance, this Christmas Trifle is ideal! Just assemble the layers then refrigerate. The only thing you’ll need to do on the day is whip the cream and pile on the fruit.

Then stand back and admire your handiwork. Beam with pride at how gorgeous your trifle looks. Enjoy that moment, because as soon as people start digging in, it will look like a complete and utter wreck. A delicious wreck. 😂 – Nagi x

Watch how to make it

Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.

Christmas Trifle

Author: Nagi

Prep: 30 mins

Cook: 10 mins

Total: 40 mins

Christmas, Dessert

British, Western

5 from 39 votes

Servings10 – 14 people

Tap or hover to scale

Print

Recipe VIDEO above. The one thing that will elevate your Trifle from "ok" to PHENOMENAL is making jelly with real cranberry juice instead of using artifical flavoured jelly. It's no different to making instant jelly – it's just that you use fruit juice and gelatine instead of flavoured jelly crystals!

Make real jelly, then you can totally get away with using store bought shortcuts for everything else – like the custard and cake.

NOTE: I used to use flavourless Aeroplane Jelly for the jelly (click here for the original recipe). It's no longer available, so the recipe uses plain gelatine instead which was preciously an alternative in the notes. Video not yet refilmed. Will do so next year!

Ingredients

CupsMetric

• ▢ 1 x 450g / 14 oz Madeira cake or Pound cake store bought (Note 1)
• ▢ 1/3 cup orange or other fruit flavoured liquor (like Cointreau), or apple, orange or other fruit juice (or 2 tbsp brandy)
• ▢ 7 tsp gelatine powder (Note 2)
• ▢ 6 cups Cranberry juice, original (ie WITH sugar added, not No Added Sugar, Note 2)
• ▢ 2 – 3 punnets strawberries, halved
• ▢ 1 each punnet blueberries, raspberries

Cream:

• ▢ 2 1/2 cups heavy / thickened cream (or pure whipping cream)
• ▢ 3 tbsp white sugar (caster sugar ok)
• ▢ 1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract

Homemade Thick Custard (or 900g 1 tub Pauls Double Thick Vanilla Custard, Note 3):

• ▢ 3 cups milk (full or low fat)
• ▢ 1/4 cup caster sugar (superfine sugar)
• ▢ 1 tsp vanilla bean paste (or extract) (Note 4)
• ▢ 1/4 cup caster sugar (superfine sugar), extra
• ▢ 4 egg yolks
• ▢ 1/2 cup cornflour / cornstarch

Instructions

• Cut cake into 3 cm / 1.2″ cubes. Cover bottom of 3.5 L / 3.5 qt trifle dish with cake (might not use all) and sprinkle with liquor or juice. 
• Optional extra: Scatter over 1/2 to 1 punnet halved strawberries (this is not in ingredients list).

Cranberry Jelly:

• Put half the cranberry juice into a saucepan over medium heat (3 cups / 750ml). Bring to a simmer, then turn off stove.
• Meanwhile, put remaining room temperature cranberry juice into a bowl. Sprinkle gelatine all across surface (don't dump in one place). Whisk until mostly dissolved.
• Pour in hot cranberry juice. Whisk until gelatin is fully dissolved. Proceed with recipe – jelly will be warm.

Jelly Layer 1:

• Pour HALF the cranberry jelly liquid carefully over the cake in the trifle dish. Refrigerate uncovered for 1.5 hours until it is partly set – still quite soft, but not watery (ie if you gently place a strawberry on it, it will stay on the surface).
• Pour remaining jelly in a bowl and leave on the counter (do not refrigerate).
• Meanwhile, make the custard (see below).

Custard Layer:

• Remove trifle from fridge. Spoon over the custard, smooth surface, press on glass to seal (stops jelly bleed). Refrigerate for 1 hour until surface has firmed up a bit – just enough to hold the jelly (jelly is soft so custard doesn’t need to be fully set). 
• Put remaining jelly in the fridge at the same time (to thicken a bit, but not too much, see video, so you get a neat, clear layer of jelly – read Note 5). CHECK jelly at 30 minutes, just to ensure it's not setting too fast.

Jelly Layer 2:

• Remove trifle and jelly from fridge. Jelly should be sloppy. Carefully spoon over jelly, smooth surface. Scatter over 1 punnet halved strawberries (or half each raspberries and strawberries). Refrigerate for 3 hours+ (can leave in fridge for 48 hours, until ready to assemble).

Assembling:

• Cream: Beat cream, sugar and vanilla until softly whipped.
• Once jelly is set, just before serving, top with cream, then pile over remaining berries. Dust with icing sugar. 
• Serve!! PS It is imperative to ensure every servings includes a bit of every layer in the trifle 😂

Homemade Custard:

• Bring milk, ¼ cup sugar and vanilla to a simmer in a large saucepan over medium heat. Do not boil.
• In a large bowl, whisk together remaining ¼ cup sugar and yolks, then whisk in cornflour until smooth.
• While whisking, carefully pour in about ½ cup of milk mixture. Once mixed in, slowly pour in remaining milk while whisking. Once incorporated and smooth, pour back into saucepan.
• Return saucepan to stove over low heat. Whisk constantly until it becomes thick and custardy – this will happen quite quickly, about 45 seconds (ie it is liquidy when you start, then suddenly it thickens). Once thickened, remove immediately from heat – it will continue to thicken.
• Pour into a bowl and cover with cling wrap, pressing onto surface. Leave on the counter until trifle is ready to layer with custard. Makes 750ml. (Note 5)

Recipe Notes:

1. CAKE: Any cake will work fine with this. Pound and Madeira are ideal and readily available at supermarkets. Homemade Vanilla Cake will also work a treat. Christmas Cake is also great but it’s a dark brown colour.

2. JELLY: Note this recipe used to be made with flavourless Aeroplane jelly (click here for the original recipe) but that is no longer available (as of 2020). Video is to be updated. Recipe always provided a plain gelatine option in the notes as an alternative so now that has become the base recipe.

Gelatine powder: I use McKenzie’s sold in the baking aisle, US: 3 x 7g sachets Knox plain gelatin, UK: 2 x 12g sachets Dr Oetker (close enough to 21g)

Cranberry juice – you MUST use Cranberry Juice with sugar added, such as Ocean Spray brand called Cranberry Classic here in Australia. Otherwise your jelly won’t be sweet at all (Cranberries are sour). Cranberry Juice is sold in the aisles.

Got the wrong juice? No worries! Just dissolve 1/2 cup white sugar into the cranberry juice heated up on the stove to make it sweet.

No artificial jelly! You’ll find many trifle versions made using raspberry and strawberry flavoured Aeroplane jelly. I find them too artificial – especially because there’s so much jelly in this dish! I really think it’s worth the small effort of making a jelly made using real Cranberry Juice, the flavour difference is astonishing, it’s real.

3. STORE BOUGHT CUSTARD: I would use store bought custard over flavoured Aeroplane Jelly, to save time. Add a dash of vanilla to freshen it up. Make sure you get DOUBLE THICK Custard (Pauls is good, Woolies, Coles etc in fridge section).

4. VANILLA BEAN PASTE has little black specks in it, like when you use an actual vanilla bean. It’s optional, you can just use normal vanilla!

5. Neat jelly layers – the first layer of jelly is poured over while liquid and will set with a flat surface and clear. The 2nd layer of jelly on the custard has to be spooned on. You can’t pour liquid jelly over custard as it breaks the custard surface no matter how gently you pour it , and the liquid jelly also seeps into the custard which cases untidy bleeding.

On the other hand, if you let the 2nd layer of jelly set then carefully spoon it on, you end up with untidy broken bits of jelly in the layer, rather than being clear.

Solution? Let the jelly only partially set, so it’s still sloppy but enough to spoon it on. It’s firm enough to create a neat layer on the custard (no bleeding) and once fully set, it’s crystal clear (rather than broken and bubbly).

6. CUSTARD: You want the custard mostly cooled but not set. When slightly cooled, it is like soft whipped cream so you can spoon it on the trifle and it spreads smoothly. If it cools too much and sets, just use an egg beater and beat until smooth. Once refrigerated in the trifle, it thickens even more – it’s not like a firm set custard that’s cut-able into clean pieces (like firm tofu), it is softer than that, it’s more like silken tofu ie. you can cut it cleanly but it’s wobbly and soft.

7. Source – I feel bad providing the recipe reference because I had issues with it, but I must because it is where the original idea came from and the end result looks so similar. I made this trifle recipe from Taste.com.au as written, I had problems with untidy layers / bleeding and I really did not enjoy the flavour of the artificial jelly. I also found the trifle didn’t fill a standard trifle dish enough. So I used this recipe as a reference point, but reconstructed it pretty much from scratch.

Keywords: Christmas dessert, christmas trifle, trifle

Did you make this recipe?I love hearing how you went with my recipes! Tag me on Instagram at @RecipeTinEats.

Life of Dozer

Dear Santa,

All I want for Christmas is for this Trifle to fall off the table.

Love, Dozer 🐾

Santa won’t be making good on that wish, but while he was sleeping, Santa accidentally flung some custard on his face and he didn’t even stir….