A bright, fresh, classic Greek Salad recipe with a homemade Greek Salad Dressing. Made properly – which means no lettuce leaves and a simple, beautiful red wine vinegar dressing!
Aussies love Greek Salad. If the local fish and chip shop sells one fresh salad, it’s probably a Greek Salad. That’s how much we love it.
Did you know……Greek Salad as most people know it (and the way I make it) is not actually the real-deal authentic Greek way. The way the Greeks make it, feta is served in a block on top of the salad rather than chopped into cubes, and the salad is dressed with just plain extra virgin olive oil (Greek olive oil of course!), not a vinaigrette. I learned on this when I saw this Perfect Greek Salad from my friend Helen at Scrummy Lane (who is obsessed with all things Greek).
Crucify me if you wish, but I prefer Greek Salad made the more common way – with feta cut into cubes (easier to eat) and with a vinaigrette rather than just olive oil (I find just olive oil too rich). But I have no doubt that if (when!!!) I get to Greece, I will be converted to the traditional way.
Though perhaps I stray from the strictly authentic Greek salad, I am a stickler for a few other “rules” that I believe in to make a classic Greek Salad:
- No lettuce – by all means, throw lettuce in if you want, but a traditional Greek salad does not have either lettuce in it;
- Best produce you can get – of course it goes without saying, especially for simple recipes like this, please get the best quality produce you can afford; and
- Plump juicy black Kalamata olives with a deep almost black colour – jarred is fine, but if you go jarred, please get a good quality one! I made a Greek salad while I was in LA in May, and I made my friend Meggan from Culinary Hill drive me to 3 grocery stores before I finally found olives I was happy with!! Not kidding! I finally found these Delallo Kalamata Olives from Ralph’s. 🙂
Though this is not a strictly authentic Greek Salad recipe, it is the way it is served at restaurants in Western countries.
Arguably one of the brightest and fresh salads around, it also happens to be one of the fastest to make because there’s no tedious chopping – I love that everything is cut into big chunks!! – Nagi x
Save this Lemon Rice Pilaf to your SIDES Pinterest Board!
And find me on Pinterest to see all the delicious things I’m pinning!
Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.
Greek Salad with Homemade Greek Salad Dressing
Ingredients
Salad
- 3 tomatoes (size of a tennis ball)
- 4 Lebanese / Persian cucumbers (about 8"/20cm long)
- 1/2 small red onion (size of a tennis ball)
- 1 small green capsicum / bell pepper
- 8 oz / 250 g feta block
- 5.5 oz / 125g black kalamata olives (Note 2)
- 1 tsp dried oregano
Greek Salad Dressing
- 1 garlic clove , minced (about 1/2 tsp minced garlic)
- 1 tsp dried oregano
- 1/4 tsp salt (or 1/2 tsp Kosher salt)
- Freshly ground black pepper
- 3 tbsp red wine vinegar
- 6 tbsp extra virgin olive oil (preferably Greek!)
Instructions
- Place Greek Salad Dressing ingredients in a jar and shake until well combined. Set aside for 20 minutes to let the flavours infuse.
- Tomatoes: Cut each tomato into 6 wedges, then cut each wedge into 3 or 4 pieces. If the tomato is watery, scoop out the watery seeds inside with a teaspoon.
- Cucumbers: Slice the cucumber into 1/2cm / 1/5" thick slices. Or if they are thick cucumbers, slice the cucumber in half vertically, then slice.
- Onion: Peel and finely slice the red onion. I keep it in rings - you could cut it in half then slice. (Note 2)
- Capsicum: Cut into short strips.
- Feta: Cut into 1cm / 2/5" cubes.
- Place the tomato, cucumber, onion, feta and olives in a bowl, sprinkle with oregano then pour over dressing. Toss to combine. Serve immediately!
Recipe Notes:
Nutrition Information:
Make this Greek Feast!
Complete with Chicken Souvlaki with Tzatziki, Easy Soft Flatbreads (No Yeast), Greek Lemon Rice and this Greek Salad.
SaveSave
Hi Nagi, could balsamic vinegar be used in place of red wine vinegar?
Hi Gail, you can if you prefer ☺️
I can’t say the words h*lly …. you know the rest but wow I’m thinking it’s perfect as eating it right now. Ok it is going on my Greek feast Xmas menu for sure. xox
Wahoo! I’m so happy you love it Sue!
Hi Nagi
Are there any substitutes for the red wine vinegar? If I bought a bottle, I wouldn’t know what else to use it for as I already have rice vinegar and white vinegar.
Thanks
Hi Annie, rice vinegar would be closest out of the two, white would be too sour unfortunately – N x
Nagi …probably the 15th time I made this salad. ❤️❤️ Went out for Greek a few nights ago. Was delish but mine (yours) is better. 🙂
Steven in flo
Wahoo, homemade is always better!
This was awesome! It was the first time my husband got excited about salad! We always order it when we eat out but now I can have it at the comfort of my own home! Thank you!
I’m so glad you loved it Nour!
The dressing and salad were delicious!
Wahoo!
A classic salad. Easy to prepare and a crowd pleaser. Like one of the commenters below, soak the red onions in the greek salad dressing to take away the sharpness of the onion. I left mine soaking for 15-20 minutes. Thanks Nagi for another wonderful and easy recipe
Great idea!
Sooooo yummy!!! Even the kids loved it. We did add romaine… That’s just the way we’re used to Greek salad in America 😉
Fabulous Alexis!
Made this tonight as written — EXCELLENT! At last I have a go-to Greek salad. We kept picking away at it until it was all gone.
Just like the salad I had in Greece! So glad you left out the lettuce; real Greek salads don’t have lettuce. Now I am craving the delicious olives from Greece.
That’s so great to hear Myndee! Thanks for letting me know you enjoyed this! N x
Yum! I love a nice fresh Greek salad. Just a tip for those that don’t like raw red onion….I always ‘marinate’ my red onion on the dressing before serving. It soaks up all the lovely juices and the onion also gives the dressing a nice tang. It is still left with a little crunch but takes the rawness out of it.
Glad you enjoyed it Lynda, thanks for letting me know! N x
That’s a fantastic tip Lynda, thanks for sharing!
This is another failsafe recipe. Went perfectly with the slow cooked greek lamb. This salad was still good for left-overs 24hrs later!
Love hearing that Claire! So glad you loved it! N x
5 star greek salad. And it is still good for left overs! It went perfectly with the slow greek lamb. Fail safe recipes!
Made this salad with a medium rare grass fed rump-amazing flavours-will make this over and over-thanks Nagi for another awesome recipe
What can I substitute for olives which I don’t like ( I know, but no one is perfect) ?
Ha ha! I understand Ferrell, don’t worry, it took me years before I enjoyed olives! Anything picked – sliced dill pickles or capers, you just want a sprinkle of something pickled to make the flavour similar. 🙂
Ah, the food memories! Why is it so difficult to find the olives you want. 🙂 I feel like I was just ill-prepared – should have taken you to Whole Foods straight away! But no matter. Glad you got the salad photos of your dreams. I’D eat that pile of goodness!!! Thanks for the shout-out!!!
I love a good fresh Greek salad (minus the fetta)!
Nagi!! I love you!!! (always did of course, but I love you even more today)
I ADORE the Greek feast you’ve made for us, and can’t wait to find out how to make that flat bread (I’m always looking for something that resembles the real pitas used in Greece for their souvlaki, and never can find it outside of Greece).
To be honest, I don’t think your Greek salad is too far removed from the ‘real’ one 😉
It looks absolutely incredible, and the main thing is… NO LETTUCE!
P.S. Thanks so much for the shout-out. Makes me want to go back and re-do my photos in that post though as I remember pulling together in a hurry an odd collection of photos I’d taken previously (the shame).
I thought you’d approve! I always think of you when I make something Greek! 🙂
Interesting fact about the original Greek salad and to be honest I’ve only seen it with lettuce here. I prefer this chunky version. Not all salads need to have greens!
True that! 🙂
Hello Nagi. As a Greek, i can tell you for sure, that your salad is absolutely Greek!!! It’s a version of Greek Salad, in many places, like Peloponnesos, where the Kalamate olives are coming from, we put both red vinegar and a clove of garlic, into the salad. With feta cheese broked in small pieces. Oregano is always a must for the salad, and no Lettuce, of course. My compliments your Greek salad is perfect!!
Thank you Cristina!! Means a lot to get such a message from a Greek! 🙂 N x
Hi Nagi! I could eat just this for dinner! I have a container of marinated kalamata olives and feta in the frig that I mixed up recently. I have to put them at the back of the shelf because if I didn’t I would see them and be into them every time I opened the frig!
Honestly Dorothy this is what I had for dinner last night!!! I was so exhausted when I got home it’s all I could manage. With a can of tuna. YUM!!!! 🙂