Not just another meatloaf……This is an Italian Meatloaf smothered in the most incredible tomato marinara sauce. Cooking the meatloaf partially submerged in the sauce makes the meatloaf extra tasty and extra juicy – not to mention all the flavour from the meatloaf dripping into the sauce!
I promise I am not exaggerating. This is not just “another meatloaf” with ground beef/mince mixed together with some random Italian herbs.
Oh no. This is so much more than that! THIS is made in the spirit of homemade Italian sausages. Have you ever made Italian sausages? I have. They taste amazing. They require speciality equipment to ground pork shoulder, electronic scales to get the exact amount of herbs and salt, and of course the sausage machine to pipe the sausage mixture into the casings.
I don’t have all that equipment in my humble kitchen. But I’ve manage to recreate the flavours in this ridiculously delicious Italian meatloaf!
As I alluded to above, the seasonings for this meatloaf are akin to homemade Italian sausages. However, I make my meatloaf with a combination of beef and pork, rather than just pork which is what Italian sausages are made of. The pork adds juiciness, the beef is the main flavour base. 🙂
The crowning glory of this is the tomato sauce. Oh my. THIS is the key differentiating factor in this recipe. Most meatloaves are not made with a sauce. But there are 2 things that make this sauce seriously delicious:
- I add the juices in the meatloaf pan into the sauce. Why throw out free flavour??
- The meatloaf finishes cooking IN the sauce. Which means all the juices from the meatloaf releases into the sauce AND the base of the meatloaf sucks up the marinara sauce flavour. Win win!
LOOK how juicy this meatloaf is! I use my secret tip to make this with bread soaked in grated onion rather than breadcrumbs. It’s the same technique I use for my Italian Meatballs that readers are raving about!
I know I rambled a bit, so here’s a quick recap of why I love this Italian meatloaf so much and why it is not like the usual:
- It actually does taste like it is Italian. It tastes like a meatloaf beef version of Italian pork sausages, thanks to the subtle combination of beef and pork mince (ground meat), red bell peppers/capsicum and fennel seeds;
- The Sauce is made extra tasty by adding the meatloaf pan juices into the sauce AND by cooking the meatloaf for part of the time IN the sauce. Flavour on flavour on flavour!
- I swear, the meatloaf is made even juicier than usual by cooking it partly submerged in the sauce. It surely must suck up some liquid??
- I also use my technique to soak bread in grated onion rather than using breadcrumbs. My theory for why this makes a difference is that the bread crumbs expand when cooked, creating little air pockets. The use of grated onion also makes this meatloaf extra tasty. This is the same technique I use to make my classic Italian Meatballs extra soft and juicy.
Have I convinced you yet that this is worth trying? 😉 – Nagi x
More meatloaf recipes
I love a good meatloaf!
- Meatloaf – extra tasty, extra juicy, extra soft!
- Chicken Meatloaf Wellington with Sun Dried Tomatoes
- Meatloaf Cupcakes With Mashed Potato
Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.
Italian Meatloaf with Marinara Sauce
Ingredients
- 1 1/2 cups diced red bell pepper / capsicum (1 large)
- 1 tbsp olive oil
- 2 cups stale white bread , crusts removed, roughly diced (about 3 slices)
- 1 small onion
- 2 tbsp cream (or milk)
- 13 oz / 400 g ground pork (mince)
- 1.6lb / 800 g ground beef (mince)
- 2 eggs
- 2 1/2 tsp fennel seeds
- 3 tsp paprika (sweet or smoked)
- 1 3/4 tsp salt
- Pepper
Sauce
- 1 tbsp olive oil
- 2 garlic cloves , minced
- 1/2 onion , finely chopped (brown, white, yellow)
- 1.4 lb / 700 g tomato passata or crushed tinned tomatoes (Note 1)
- 3/4 cup water
- 2 tsp dried Mixed Italian Herbs
- 1 - 3 tsp red pepper flakes (optional)
- Salt and pepper
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 180C/350F. Spray a 28cm/11" loaf pan, then line with parchment / baking paper, leaving overhang (Note 2).
- Heat oil over high heat. Add capsicum, leave for 1 minute without stirring so it starts to char (burn) then stir and continue cooking to char it more (about 2 minutes in total). Remove and set aside.
- Place bread in a large bowl. Grate onion into the bowl, using a normal box cutter (Note 3). Add cream, then use your hands to squidge the mixture together so the bread is completely soaked and starts to disintegrate.
- Add remaining meatloaf ingredients, including capsicum. Use your hands to mix it together until JUST combined. Do not over mix otherwise it will become dense.
- Press into the loaf pan (Note 4). Drizzle with olive oil then bake for 30 minutes. Meanwhile, make the Sauce.
- Take the meatloaf out of the oven. Carefully lift the meatloaf out of the loaf pan (using the paper overhang) onto a work surface. Then transfer the meatloaf into the skillet with the Sauce.
- Pour juices in the loaf pan into the skillet. Return to the oven for a further 30 to 40 minutes, or until cooked to your liking.
- Take it out of the oven and let it rest for 5 minutes before slicing. Serve the meatloaf with the Sauce, garnished with parmesan if desired.
- I like to serve this with mashed potatoes but it is also lovely with pasta.
Sauce
- Heat oil in a ovenproof skillet over medium heat. Add onion and garlic and cook for 3 minutes until translucent.
- Add remaining ingredients. Bring to a simmer and cook for 5 minutes on the stove, adjusting salt and pepper to taste.
- Take it off the stove. Follow the steps above to place the meatloaf in and bake it.
Recipe Notes:
Nutrition Information:
SaveSave
Very creative. Can’t wait til I try.
I hope you do!
My husband is allergic to bell peppers. What can I use as a substitute in this recipe?
Absolutely delicious, my family really loved it. Merci beaucoup!
That’s great! I’m so pleased to hear that, thanks for taking the time to leave a review! N x
Hey Nagi! We don’t have any bread in the house so I was thinking to substitute in dried breadcrumbs. Do you think that would work?
Thanks!!
Hi Jess! Yup, use 3/4 cup. It isn’t quite as super soft as these inside, but still lovely and soft! N x
I made this just the other day exactly as written. The best part about this is that it automatically makes 2 meals for my family. First night meatloaf and potatoes with veg and the next night, pasta with leftover meat(loaf) sauce and a salad! LOVE this kind of cooking. Thank you!
Fantastic! So glad to hear that Amy, thanks so much for letting me know! N x
I can see green stuff, probably parsley in your meatloaf Nagi, but I cannot see it in the Recipe, what gives. I added parsley anyway and a bit a parmesan cheese to the mix, it was delish , thanks once again.
Hi Sharyn! I think you are referring to the photo with the slice of meatloaf and in that one, I scattered parsley over it and the potatoes 🙂 So glad you liked it, thanks so much for letting me know! N x
Hi Nagi, this looks delicious. I want to make it early in the day for dinner Any advice ?
Hi Karin! This reheats great! Just cook it then refrigerate after cooling, add a splash of water into the sauce if it gets too thick for your liking 🙂
Could this be made and then frozen for later?
Yes it can! Separate sauce from meat 🙂
YO GIRL! You Rock! This recipe is the headliner online on how “Celebrity chefs” make blow-your-mind meatloaf. You’re a celebrity chef! YIPPPPPPEEEEEEEE
BA HA HA! I’m NOT at all!!! I’m just a home cook!!! (But yes I saw that and YES it sounded awesome!!!! I’m not a Chef NOR a Celebrity!!!) N x
Hi Nagi,
This looks delicious and I’m going to make it this weekend. I’m going to increase the beef and pork portions a bit as I’m making it for 8 people who have hearty appetites. Maybe by a half or maybe I should just make two and freeze one. 2 tsp dried Mixed Italian Herbs If I cannot find a mix, what spices should I use? Also, if I use a pyrex baking dish, do I still need to use parchment? And, is it ok to use a stainless steel pot? It looks like you have one with a ceramic interior…
Thanks!
Gilbert
Hi Gilbert! I think it’s easiest just to make two and freeze leftovers, this freezes very well, both the meatloaf and the sauce! If you can’t find mixed Italian herbs, I would use a general mixed herb mix OR use any combo of: basil, parsley, thyme, oregano. They are all classic Italian herbs. A pinch of dried red pepper is always a great addition too! If you use pyrex, I think you won’t need parchment paper and YES it is ok to use a stainless steel pot as long as the meatloaf fits and it’s ovenproof! N x
Have never made meatloaf before, but this came out beautifully after following your instructions. Very moist and flavoursome, the whole family enjoyed it. thanks!
I’m so glad to hear that you enjoyed it Diana! Thank you for letting me know! N x
This was AMAZING!!!!! My husband loved it, all 3 kids loved it even my picky eater!!! AND we had this sauce left over and ate it with pasta!!!!! It was a SUPER AWESOME sauce!!!! Thank you 🙂
YEE HAA!!! SO GLAD you enjoyed it Doremi!!! 🙂
I never Made meatloaf in my life and this one happend to be the first one ever ,and OMG, it was soooo good juice and yummieee,my boyfriend can’t stop talking about it,he ate so much.
Love love love your page Nagi,much Love. 😀
Woo hoo!!! SO GLAD you loved it Liz! N x
Perfection. I do make homemade Italian sausage. Beats the heck out of store bought. Used fire roasted peppers and made my own sauce from fire roasted tomatoes from my garden. Processed them last year. I use a blow torch to char them. Don’t laugh, my family thinks I slipped of the rail as well. Served it with fresh pasta and pull apart garlic bread. No leftovers here.
I am SO JEALOUS that you make your own sausages! I don’t have the machine. 🙂 PS I would never laugh. I would use a blow torch too, if I had one! Save me firing up the BBQ! 🙂
I charred my peppers and tomatoes on my gas dcs stove (with tongs) works wonders and much safer then using a blow torch.
Great tip Bonny, thanks! 🙂
Nothing beats a meatloaf….this is making me very hungry!
Thanks so much Jen!! 🙂
I am making this for dinner tonight, it’s supposed to be “spring” but winter’s Rolling back in
And it’s supposed to be autumn here but still feels like summer!!!