Aussie Lemon Coconut Slice Cake

This is the cakey kind of Lemon Coconut Slice, with a lemon coconut butter cake topped with lemon icing, cut into little squares so it’s perfect with a cuppa. And because the icing is the crusting sort, it’s practical for bake sales or tucking into lunch boxes!

Aussie Lemon Coconut Slice Cake

I’m sure this style of cake isn’t exclusively Australian, but I call it Australian because it’s a copycat of lemon cake slices I grew up seeing in cafes and at school bake sales. These days, you’ll even find packaged versions in grocery stores!

It’s a thin lemon butter cake cut into handheld pieces and thickly iced with a glaze that crusts on the surface, making it practical for wrapping, stacking and transporting without frosting smearing everywhere. Sometimes it has coconut in it, sometimes it doesn’t. I like it with, so mine does!

I’ve seen it called Lemon Slice, but to me that means a compact base topped with lemon curd, like these Lemon Bars. In my simple mind, bars and slices have compact bases, whereas this is actually a thin cake. Hence the awkward name – Lemon Coconut Slice Cake!

Ingredients in Aussie Lemon Coconut Slice Cake

Here’s what you need to make this.

1. For the cake part

• 1 very big lemon or 2 regular lemons – We need 1 tablespoon of zest and 2 tablespoons of juice for the cake, and 7 – 8 teaspoons for the icing. Fun fact: lemon flavour is in the zest. The juice just makes things tangy. 🙂

• Flour – Just plain / all-purpose flour, not self-raising flour (wrong about of baking powder built in).

• Desiccated coconut – This is the finely shredded type that is like panko breadcrumb size, called shredded coconut or finely shredded coconut in the US. Not shavings or flakes (too large), not coconut powder. Make sure it’s unsweetened (standard in Australia).

• Baking powder – This is what makes the cake rise. We only need 1 teaspoon. Don’t substitute with baking soda, the cake gets a bit of a hump in the middle (we want flat for this slice-cake).

• Unsalted butter – Softened to room temperature so it can be creamed.

• White sugar – Caster / superfine sugar if you’ve got it (it’s finer so dissolves more easily) other regular sugar works too (granulated sugar).

• Large eggs – Eggs around ~50 – 55g/2oz each, from a carton labelled “large eggs” (which are 600g for a dozen which suggests 50g each, but not all eggs are exactly the same weight – selfish hens! Why can’t they lay exactly the same size eggs every single time!! 🙄😆).

• Milk – Just regular milk is the liquid for this cake! Make sure the milk is at room temperature as fridge cold milk can make butter solidify and you’ll up with greasy little butter pockets in the cake, and it won’t rise as well.

• Salt – Just a tiny amount, to bring out the flavours in everything else.

2. For the thick glaze icing

This icing is actually just a glaze, but I make it very thick so it spreads like a buttercream frosting rather than a typical runny glaze that is see-through and runs down the side of the cake. It will set with a crust on the surface and it’s not greasy like buttercream, which makes these slices really practical – you can stack them, wrap them in cling wrap, pack them into lunch boxes and bundle in gift bags without icing smearing everywhere.

Here’s what you need:

• Soft icing sugar / powdered sugar – If you’re in Australia, get the type of icing sugar called SOFT Icing Sugar rather than PURE Icing Sugar (which sets harder, like royal icing). If not presented with these options, just get what you can. 🙂

• Lemon juice – This is the liquid to make the icing. We only use a very small amount – 7 to 8 teaspoons for 2 cups of icing sugar – which sounds like nowhere near enough, I know! But trust me, keep mixing and smearing and that enormous pile of icing sugar will come together into a thick, smooth icing that stays on the surface rather than running down the sides like typical glazes.

• Desiccated coconut – For sprinkling.

How to make an Aussie Lemon Coconut Slice Cake

The most important thing with this recipe is to ensure the eggs and milk are at room temperature, not fridge cold, else the butter will solidify and you’ll get little hards bits of butter in the batter rather than mixing in smoothly.

Oh – also! Don’t use a stand mixer. The volume of batter is so small, you will spend more time scraping down the sides than actual mixing time. (I tried, it was a pain!)

1. Dry ingredients – Mix the dry ingredients in a medium bowl (flour, coconut, baking powder and salt).

2. Cream butter and sugar – Using a handheld beater (don’t use a stand mixer, there’s not enough batter), cream the butter and sugar for 2 minutes until it’s light and fluffy. Start on low speed so you don’t get sugar spraying everywhere, then increase the speed to high when you can.

3. Beat in the eggs one at a time until it’s mix in, then the lemon juice, zest and vanilla. The batter will look a little curdled once the lemon goes in but it’s ok, it will come together into a smooth batter when the flour is added.

4. Flour and milk, alternating – Add 1/3 of the flour mixture and beat on low speed just until the flour is mixed in, then stop. Add half the milk, beat on low just until incorporated, then repeat again with half the remaining flour, beat, milk, beat, then remaining flour and beat. Stop when you can no longer see flour.

   Using this method minimises the mixing required to incorporate all the flour and milk (ie if you dump them all in one go, you have to beat for longer to mix in), and less mixing = softer cake. Over mixing batter = hard cake!

5. Finish by hand – Use a rubber spatula to sweep around the bowl and mix in any stray bits of flour.

6. Pour into a 20cm/8″ square pan lined with paper and smooth the surface.

7. Bake for 30 minutes at 180°C/350°F (160°C fan) or until a toothpick inserted into the centre comes out clean.

8. Cool upside down – Cool in the pan for 5 minutes, then turn it out onto a rack and cool it upside down. This gives us a perfect flat surface for icing.

9. Icing (frosting) – This is a very thick glaze, almost like buttercream, so it sits on the cake rather than running down the sides. Mix the icing sugar and lemon juice with a rubber spatula using firm smearing motions. It will seem impossibly dry at first, but persevere – at first it will turn into a dough-like mixture, then into smooth thick icing. Aim for a peanut butter consistency: spreadable, not drippy. If needed, add more lemon juice just 1/2 teaspoon at a time – glazes go from too thick to too runny very quickly, so use a tiny bit at a time!

10. Ice and shower – Once the cake is completely cool, spread the icing on from edge to edge. Sprinkle with desiccated coconut, then let the icing set for half an hour before slicing into squares or bars to enjoy!

Stays fresh for a week

Another very appealing feature of this cake is that it stays fresh for a week, thanks to the coconut which adds moisture into the cake. Nice not to have to resort to any bakers’ tricks for keeping this cake moist like buttermilk, yogurt, sour cream or oil!

In fact, I swear the cake was even softer and tasted better on day 2, once the lemon and coconut flavours had settled in and the moisture had worked its way through the crumb. A cake that improves overnight and stays fresh for a week – what more could you ask for! 🙂 – Nagi x

---

Watch how to make it

For lemon lovers 🍋🍋🍋

---

Life of Jaffle

The idea for this cake came with the first ripe lemons on my dwarf lemon tree, which of course immediately became Jaffle’s favourite toys. Because that’s the rule, right? Everything that’s mine is his!

Though, he trotted off gleefully with his prize and I think he gave it a few enthusiastic squeezes in his mouth that must have released a bitter little spritz of lemon because he suddenly stopped, looking confused and unimpressed. 😂