Meat Pie recipe!

The great Australian Meat Pie!! Shortcrust pastry filled with slow cooked chunky pieces of beef in a rich gravy topped with golden puff pastry, this meat pie recipe requires patience but you will be regarded as a bloody legend by everybody fortunate enough to try one!

It’s way better than your everyday bakery and will rival some of the best meat pie makers in town – Bourke Street Bakery included! Bonus: old school beef mince meat pie recipe included.

Australian meat pie recipe!!

From midnight post-pub feasting to footy games, quick lunches on the run to essential road trip pit stops, Aussies never need an excuse to get stuck into meat pies!

That moment when you bite through the buttery, flaky golden puff pastry and the molten filling comes oozing out, and you frantically fan your mouth while mumbling “hot, hot, hot!!!”, cursing yourself for not letting it cool down but on the other hand you just don’t bloody care about third degree mouth burns because the pie is SO SO SO GOOD…..

That moment is something that every (non-vegetarian) Aussie is very familiar with.

And it’s a moment that Aussies who have moved abroad miss so much.

So today’s meat pie recipe is dedicated to all Aussies living overseas. Your hunt for a meat pie fix is officially over!!

How to make meat pies

It’s not the fastest recipe in the world – truthfully, it’s quite fiddly – but I absolutely promise it’s worth it. Here’s an overview – and the video below is quite helpful. 🙂

• Pie crust base – shortcrust pastry (homemade or store bought) fitted into pie tins then blind baked so they don’t go soggy once filled. Don’t have pie tins? Use large muffin tins or ramekins, or make one giant pie! I got mine from Woolies.

• Meat Pie Filling – just like making a beef stew, it’s cooked long and slow so the beef becomes ultra tender and the sauce develops incredible deep, rich flavours; and

• Puff pastry pie topping – the crowning glory of the Aussie meat pie experience is that flaky golden puff pastry topping! Store bought, all the way for me. 🙂

Why two types of pastry?

I use shortcrust for the base because it won’t go soggy and has the strength so you can pick the pie up with your hands. Then puff pastry for that classic flaky meat pie lid we love and know so well!

Meat Pie Filling

Here’s what goes in the meat pie filling. This is for a chunky meat pie – pieces of beef slow cooked until fall apart tender which makes an intensely deep, rich flavoured gravy.

The old school version is made with beef mince (ground beef) but the flavour of chunky beef pies is better because you can brown the pieces beautifully which forms the flavour base for the sauce.

After an old school beef mince version?

For a beef mince version, just swap the chuck beef for beef mince and read the recipe notes for how to tweak the recipe. The sauce needs a flavour bump because it will be missing the flavour boost you get from browning cubes of beef – this step is key to a really great meat pie sauce!

Meat Pie pastry

The base of meat pies is made with shortcrust pastry and the lids are made with puff pastry. For convenience, use store bought for both if you wish. In Australia, shortcrust pastry comes frozen in square sheets. If you’re in the US or Canada, use refrigerated pie crusts (the rolled up type).

I like to make the shortcrust pastry because I feel like there’s high returns for small effort (using a food processor, it’s a 5 minute job).

But I always use store bought puff pastry – I’ve made it once, and it’s probably the only time I ever will in my life!

Meat Pie recipe tips

• Brown the beef VERY well – this is key to ensure your filling has a rich complex flavour and is a deep dark brown colour. Brown in small batches – don’t crowd the pot otherwise the beef will stew in its own juices and will never brown! If this happens, just take some out.

• Beef mince version – use recipe tweaks in the notes to give the sauce a flavour boost (because mince doesn’t brown like using cubes of beef)

• Chunky vs beef mince – no question, chunky is superior in flavour and overall eating experience! Just can’t achieve the same sauce flavour using mince (but still so SO tasty!)

• Start the day before – if you can. Firstly, it’s best for the filling to be fridge cold to ensure the meat pie base doesn’t go soggy. Secondly, as with all stews, the filling is even better the next day!

• Don’t reduce the sauce too much. Some liquid evaporates while the filling is cooling and liquid gets absorbed by the pie crust. When you cut open the pie, you want the filling to ooze out and be nice and saucy, not dry.

• Don’t make the pie crust too thin – if making your own shortcrust pastry, don’t make the base too thin otherwise it will break when the pie is picked up. Still tasty – but very messy!

• To smear or not to smear?? To this day, I cannot believe there are people who eat meat pies without tomato sauce. I really try to respect personal preferences….. but I will never understand! 😂

• Hands – or knife and fork? Knife and fork?? Shame on you! The Aussie meat pie is made for eating with your hands!!!🤣

Worth the effort!

It will take you the better part of a day to make homemade meat pies. It’s quite involved and they’re especially fiddly because we’re making individual pies rather than one large pie.

But you will be regarded as a bloody legend by everybody fortunate enough to put one of these pies in their pie-hole!

Are they as good as what you can buy? YES. Better than your everyday bakery by a long shot, even using store bought pastry. Way WAY better than the average frozen meat pies from the supermarket.

That moment when you pull these golden beauties out of the oven – you’ll feel both excited AND smug (as you should……)

But then, you smear the still-hot-from-the-oven meat pie with some tomato sauce, and take a huge bite….

O.M.G.

There are no words. (But I shall try)

You’ve got a mouthful of buttery shortcrust pastry that literally melts in your mouth, juicy fall apart beef smothered in a rich gravy with flavour money can’t buy, and the flaky crispy puff pastry…..

Be still my beating heart.

There is simply no question. It’s one of the best food experiences in the world! – Nagi x

🇦🇺More Aussie fare🇦🇺

• Party Pies (Aussie Mini Beef Pies) – Mini meat pies!

• Sausage Rolls – Seasoned pork mixture rolled up in puff pastry. We believe this rivals Bourke St Bakery too!😂

• Lamingtons – Vanilla sponge cubes dipped in chocolate and coated with coconut

• Anzac biscuits – Crispy, buttery, toffee flavoured oatmeal cookies

• Pavlova!! – Crispy meringue on the outside, marshmallow on the inside, piled high with cream and fruit

• Scones – Plus magic 3 ingredient Lemonade Scones (3 ingredients)

Watch how to make it

Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.

Aussie Meat Pie recipe

Author: Nagi

Prep: 40 mins

Cook: 3 hrs 40 mins

Filling cooling: 4 hrs

Total: 4 hrs 20 mins

Mains

Australian

4.99 from 50 votes

Servings6

Tap or hover to scale

Print

Recipe video above. The great Australian meat pie - made at home! Buttery shortcrust base filled with slow cooked fall apart chunky beef smothered in a rich gravy, topped with puff pastry. Legendary! {See notes for beef mince version}

Ingredients

Pie Base - Choose ONE (Note 1):

• ▢ 1 1/2 batches homemade shortcrust pastry
• ▢ 3 frozen shortcrust pastry sheets, thawed (300g/10oz)
• ▢ 2 refrigerated pie crusts (US/Can)

Pie Lid:

• ▢ 3 frozen puff pastry sheets, just thawed (300g/10oz) (Note 2)
• ▢ 1 egg , lightly whisked

Filling:

• ▢ 1.25 kg / 2.5lb beef chuck , 2.5cm/1" cubes (Note 3)
• ▢ 1/2 tsp each salt & pepper
• ▢ 2 - 3 tbsp olive oil
• ▢ 1 onion , diced
• ▢ 4 garlic cloves , minced
• ▢ 5 tbsp flour , plain/all purpose
• ▢ 1 1/4 cups (315 ml) beef stock, low sodium (Note 4)
• ▢ 3 cups (750 ml) red wine , dry full bodied (Note 5)
• ▢ 2 tbsp tomato paste
• ▢ 1 tsp Worcestershire sauce
• ▢ 2 tsp black pepper , coarsely ground
• ▢ 2 bay leaves

Instructions

Filling:

• Sprinkle beef with 1/2 tsp salt and pepper.
• Heat 1 tbsp oil in a large heavy based pot over high heat. Add 1/3 of the beef and brown aggressively all over, then remove. Repeat with remaining beef, adding more oil if needed.
• Turn stove down to medium high. Add garlic and onion, cook 3 minutes.
• Add flour, stir through.
• Slowly add beef stock while stirring constantly. Once flour is dissolved, add wine, tomato paste, Worcestershire, pepper and bay leaves.
• Return beef into pot, cover with lid, adjust heat so it's simmering gently.
• Simmer 1 hr 45 minutes. Remove lid, increase heat slightly and simmer 30 - 45 minutes, stirring regularly, or until beef is fork tender and liquid reduces down to a thickish gravy, just about covering beef (see video). Do not reduce liquid too much - thickens more as it cools & in pie.
• Remove from stove, cover and cool filling (I usually leave overnight).

Pastry:

• Preheat oven to 180C/350F.
• Cut out 6 rounds from the shortcrust pastry, then drape pastry into pie tins - don't stretch and pull pastry, causes shrinkage. (Notes 1 & 6)
• Place pies on tray. Top each pie with large sheets of parchment / baking paper and fill with pie weights (Note 7).
• Bake 20 minutes, remove, then use paper overhang to carefully remove pie weights.
• Return crusts into oven for 5 minutes or until base is light golden and dry (can skip, Note 8). Remove from oven.

Assemble pies:

• Fill pies with cooled filling, push down to fill. Should be slightly mounded.
• Cut rounds from partially thawed puff pastry - cut them slightly larger than the edge of the cooked pastry bases.
• Brush edge of pie crusts with egg, then place lid on filling, pressing edges to seal puff pastry to the shortcrust pastry.
• Brush lids with egg, then cut a 1cm / 0.5" incision in the middle using a small knife.
• Bake 30 minutes or until deep golden and puffed.
• Devour hot and fresh, topped with tomato sauce or ketchup if desired!

Recipe Notes:

1. Shortcrust pastry - options:

Homemade - make 1 1/2 batches of homemade shortcrust pastry (click Servings and slide to scale recipe). Roll out to 2 - 3mm / 1/10" thick then cut rounds. Make sure it's not paper thin because otherwise it won't be strong enough to withhold all the filling!

Frozen shortcrust pastry - comes in 20cm/8" square sheets here in Australia. Thaw then line up to overlap edges slightly and press down to seal edges (to make one long sheet, reduces waste). Cut rounds.

Refrigerated rolled pie crusts (US/Can) - such as Pillsbury. Unroll and cut rounds as required by this recipe. Press together scraps if needed to make enough rounds. Pack will probably say no pre-baking required before filling. For this recipe, pre-baking is recommended to avoid soggy base (meat pies are meant to be eaten by hand!)

Cutting rounds - Use tape measure to measure from edge to edge of pie tin, pressing down into the dish. Then find anything that is around that size - I used a saucepan lid! 

Make sure rounds are big enough so it covers the lip of the pie tin as well - better to have pastry too large than too small, it will shrink slightly.

2. Puff pastry here in Australia comes in 20cm/8" square sheets. I get 2 lids out of each so there is quite a bit of leftover from each sheet. Quick ways to use up scraps:

• Brush with melted butter, sprinkle with cinnamon and sugar, cut sticks/shapes bake until golden. Try garlic butter, sprinkle with parmesan and pepper, or dukkdah or zaatar. Or just bake sticks plain and use as dippers with soups or stews.

3. Beef - chuck beef nicely marble with fact is ideal for this recipe. Boneless short rib also works great. Do not try this with gravy beef - too lean. See note below for beef mince.

4. Beef stock - recipe doesn't use much beef stock because I find that store bought beef stock can give the filling a slight artificial flavour edge, also can make it too salty because the liquid is reduced down and concentrated. Flavour base relies heavily on the browning of the beef + wine + slow cooking.

5. Red wine - merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, shiraz, Burgundy, Zinfandel, malbec, Tempranillo all good here. Avoid sweet ones and light reds like pinot noirs, Grenache. Use this chart as a guide - anything from Merlot or bolder will be great! 

I know this sounds like a lot of wine but the slow cooking cooks out the wine flavour and alcohol, plus the sauce reduces down a lot into a rich, deeply flavoured gravy. Using too much beef stock isn't ideal here because once reduced, the flavour is too strong.

6. Pie tins - I used pie tins from Woolies (Australia), 10 cm / 4". Can also make them in ramekins (this is what I used to do before I got pie tins), Texas muffin tins (the large ones), mini pies in normal muffin tins (then it's Party Pies!) or one large pie dish (use leftover filling to make pie triangles using puff pastry!).

Fitting pastry into pie tins - drape and gently push in, do not stretch and pull pastry (this will cause pastry to shrink when it bakes).

7. Pie weights - heatproof marble size beads that weigh down the pastry to stop it from puffing and shrinking while it bakes. Sub with dried rice, dried beans or similar (save to reuse again as pie weights).

8. Pastry 2nd bake - this is just to dry the base out and make it crisp, if not needed then skip the 2nd pastry bake.

9. Beef mince - old school meat pies are made with beef mince but chunky style are more highly regarded for flavour and eating experience! Can't get the same browning with mince, hence why sauce flavour is not quite as good. To make super tasty beef mince meat pies - completely skip salt, use beef cube and dark soy instead (doesn't taste Asiany, adds flavour and colour to sauce otherwise it's a pale unappetising brown colour):

• Cook onion and garlic, then add 1.3 kg / 2.6lb beef mince (ground beef) and brown
• Add flour and remaining ingredients per recipe including pepper but DO NOT ADD SALT
• Add 1 beef cube, crumbled
• Simmer gently, covered, for 1 hr 20 minutes
• Uncover and reduce for 20 minutes
• Add up to 1 tsp dark soy sauce to make the sauce colour a nice brown and add flavour (soy has more flavour than plain salt), simmer for 5 min. Add normal salt if you want it saltier.
• Cool then use as filling per recipe.

10. Storage - Cooked pies keep in the fridge for up to 5 days, best to give it a quick microwave to warm the centre then pop in the oven for 5 minutes at 180C/350F to crisp pastry. OR wrap in cling wrap then freeze cooked pies, thaw then reheat in oven at 180C/350F for 20 minutes until centre is piping hot. Can also freeze pies once filled and topped with raw uncooked puff pastry.

11. Nutrition per pie. Best estimate taking into account unused pastry, erred on the high side to be conservative.

Nutrition Information:

Calories: 825cal (41%)Carbohydrates: 43g (14%)Protein: 46g (92%)Fat: 41g (63%)Saturated Fat: 14g (88%)Cholesterol: 165mg (55%)Sodium: 759mg (33%)Potassium: 1074mg (31%)Fiber: 1g (4%)Sugar: 2g (2%)Vitamin A: 145IU (3%)Vitamin C: 3.1mg (4%)Calcium: 71mg (7%)Iron: 7.5mg (42%)

Keywords: Australian Meat Pie, Meat Pie

Did you make this recipe?I love hearing how you went with my recipes! Tag me on Instagram at @RecipeTinEats.

Life of Dozer

Ironclad grip on both Dozer and coffee (equally important at early morning beach sessions)