Did you know you can make ahead mashed potatoes? It’s a restaurant trick!
Whenever you order a dish with mashed potatoes at a restaurant, did you ever wonder whether they peeled, boiled and mashed the potatoes to order? No they don’t!
Restaurants prepare the potatoes ahead by boiling and mashing just the potato, then just before serving, it is mixed into boiling cream (or milk or even broth or a combination thereof) to reheat it and make it nice and creamy.
When it comes to ridiculously creamy restaurant style mashed potatoes, there’s not much to it. The secret is just loads of cream and butter. The creamier the mashed potato, the more cream and butter it has in it!
Here’s another little tip for you – if your pot is a bit small and there is risk of the bubble overflowing, just place a wooden spoon across the top. No more overflow!
Mashed potatoes are a “must have” for special occasion feasts like Thanksgiving and Christmas. So having this make-ahead trick on hand is very useful! – Nagi x
PS Use any leftovers to make mashed potato cakes!
Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.
Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes (Restaurant Trick)
Ingredients
- 2 lb / 1 kg starchy potatoes (Note 1)
- 1 cup / 250 ml cream , half and half or milk (Note 2)
- 60g / 1/4 cup butter
- Salt and pepper
To Serve
- Olive oil
- Chives , finely chopped
- Pepper
Instructions
- Peel and cut the potatoes into large chunks.
- Bring a pot of water to the boil, then add the potatoes. Cook for 20 minutes until soft and starting to fall apart.
- Drain then tip back into the pot placed over the stove (turned off). Allow to steam dry for a few minutes.
- Mash to your taste. Do NOT use a hand held mixer, blender or food processor - it will activate the starches in the potatoes and make it gluey.
- To make ahead, transfer to a bowl and cover with cling wrap, pressing onto the potato to remove as much air as possible. Refrigerate up to 2 days until required.
- On the day of, place the cream and butter in a pot and bring to a boil. Turn the stove off but leave the pot on the stove. Add the potatoes and stir into the cream.
- If you want to make your potatoes creamier, push them to the side, add more cream/milk, turn the stove on, bring to a simmer then stir.
- Season with salt and pepper.
- Serve warm, garnished with chopped chives, a drizzle of olive oil and pepper.
Recipe Notes:
melli says
Hi nagi what do you mean by half and half or milk? Im sorry non native english speaker here.
Nagi says
Hi Melli! I should have added a note 🙂 It’s half cream half milk and sold that way in the US. Here in Australia I mix my own (if cooking for company) or just use milk (for every day purposes). N x
Carolyn says
I realize this is an old post, but thought I’d ask and see if I got a response! 🙂 These potatoes sounds great and I love that I can largely make the day or 2 before. But, when you heat the cream/butter, turn off burner, add potatoes and mix… do the potatoes get truly warm? I just want to be sure I will be serving my guests delicious warm potatoes (and not having to place individual plates into the microwave to warm up).
Thanks! Hope I get a response!
Nagi says
Hi Carolyn! It truly does 🙂 You need to use a decent size pot, not a tiny saucepan. The mash gets heat from the cream and pot. And if need be, just turn the stove on for a bit – minimum time necessary. And the mash gets hot/warm, not piping hot like it was freshly made. N x
JULIA says
Hi Nagi. Can you freeze the boiled mashed potatoes then defrost and add butter etc?
Nagi says
Hi Julia! To freeze mashed potato, add the butter and cream THEN freeze it 🙂 It freezes much better that way! Then freeze in bags to save space, and reheat in the microwave 🙂
Mark Ikemeier says
Your recipe for mashed is very good. I however, enjoy adding cheese, cheddar or American preferably. It adds a unique flavor profile and opens a wide choice of palate flavors.
Nagi says
I hear you Mark. Adding cheese into mash is the BEST!!!!
Mechelf says
I can’t wait to try this! Make ahead is great, it eliminates the need for mother-in-law to supervise?
Nagi | RecipeTin says
BA HA HA!!! That’s RIGHT!!!
Mila Furman says
Sadly for our wastelines that is the trick 🙂 But nothing is as good as perfectly creamy mashers!!!!
Nagi | RecipeTin says
I know, right? Cream cream more cream, butter butter more butter….so GOOD!!
Patti Leathers says
If you mash the taters with sour cream and cream cheese instead of most or all of the milk(and, of course, butter), you can refrigerate them for a couple of days and reheat them in the oven. Yummy.
Maureen says
I would like to try cream cheese & sour cream not sure how much to add in & is this in place of the half n half ?
Patti Leathers says
I just mix globs in and sample as I go. Obviously I could never write a cookbook!!
Nagi | RecipeTin says
Oooh…..I have heard about the cream cheese trick too 🙂 I haven’t tried that myself yet but I think I will!
Patti Leathers says
It’s yummy….a bit of tang. Don’t forget the sour cream and butter….lots of all three!
Mila Furman says
Nagi it’s true!!! My creamy dreamy mashers have cream cheese and sour cream in it… I think it’s THE BEST combo.
Nagi | RecipeTin says
Can’t believe I haven’t tried it yet….